What is an Original Print in Fine Art Photography?

Photographer Statue, Bratislava, 2007

As I develop my new direction I am grappling with what constitutes art photography and what constitutes an "original", something that is so important in the art market generally. Ansel Adams (1902-1984) said:

The negative is comparable to the composer's score and the print to its performance. Each performance differs in subtle ways.

That was probably true in his day but now in our digital world the negative (or now the scanned or raw digital file) is the score, the digital post-production work is the performance and everyone (who can afford it) can have a print (or digital display file) that is the equivalent of a DVD of a musical performance. Each one is a consistent record of that performance, of the printer's interpretation of the raw image whether negative or digital).

Unlike an Adams print each modern print one will not be subtly different (or only to the extent that a recording played on different hi-fi will sound subtly different, or in this case produced on different printer or paper)

Obviously this does not apply to those photographers who are working, like Adam, with last century technology. That is not to denigrate those who choose to do so, after all we admire modern artists who are using essentially oil paint technology with which 16th century painters would be comfortable. But then there are artists using the best of modern materials, such as acrylic paints or machine tools to do their sculpting. It all comes down to how the individual sees their art and what is important.

For me, in all forms of 2D art, it is the content not the medium that is important, the medium is only important to the extent it affects the artist's message. The same composition painted in watercolour and oils would produce two very different interpretations that would affect how the content is received by the viewer.

I am therefore inclined to the view that the original is that which was produced in the camera; the negative or the original file. Everything else is part of what Adams described as the performance

But as important as the negative or raw file is, it is very much the starting point - the score. So is the artist the printmaker who turns that score into a performance that moves the audience? Is the printmaker in fact the conductor or the musician? In that case is the printmaker the real artist?

Why is it that in music the composer and the performer are usually different but in photography they are the same. Unlike composers do photographers not trust others in this case the printmaker to produce a satisfactory performance, recognising that they are different but complimentary skills? In music we regard the composer and the musician/ conductor as artists bring different skills to the art work. There have been photographers who worked closely with printmakers to realise their vision on paper but the printer is largely unsung, only known to a few aficionados.

So while I don't have a definitive answer as to what constitutes an original in photography I do have a model with which I am reasonably comfortable. The photographer is the composer, the post-production technician who creates the print file, who may also be the photographer, produces the performance which is the result of their combined skills. The print or other image is then simply a record of that performance just as a  CD or DVD is a recording of other forms of artistic performance.

I can live with that as it helps me with shaping the form of my artistic offerings. It leads me on nicely to the question of limited edition prints and subsequently to pricing of my as yet undefined art works. I will share my thinking on those matters in future post in this Journal.

Add new comment